Columns

Harry KingHARRY KING
Sports Columnist for The Morning News

Robbie NeiswangerROBBIE NEISWANGER
Sports Columnist for The Morning News



Sponsors

Analysis: Coaching Search Bungled, But Salvageable

Last updated Saturday, March 31, 2007 9:50 PM CDT
in Razorback Central

By Ryan Malashock
The Morning News

FAYETTEVILLE -- Seven days now.

Arkansas has been without a men's basketball coach now for seven days, much longer than any of those close to the program expected.

And all kinds of questions have arisen since Stan Heath was fired on Monday, 10 days after completing his second straight appearance in the NCAA Tournament and his second straight 20-win season.

In no particular order, the following queries have consumed Razorbacks fans throughout this dramatic, frustrating and, at times, mortifying week for them:

* Was it really necessary to let Heath go, coming off two straight 20-win seasons with him bringing back the best team of his tenure?

* Why is Arkansas Athletic Director Frank Broyles is leading the search by himself?

* How did Texas A&M coach Billy Gillispie get away? Wasn't that supposed to be a done deal?

* How much money can Arkansas afford to spend for a coach as salaries skyrocket around the country?

* And, last but certainly not least, who will be the next coach?

Well, to start with, the decision to fire Heath already appears suspect.

Arkansas hired Heath in 2002 to replace Nolan Richardson. Just days before, in his only season as a head coach, Heath took Kent State to the Elite Eight of the NCAA Tournament.

Fans and university officials knew the road to a program turnaround was a long and twisty one. Richardson even told Heath that he didn't leave him much with which to work.

Heath managed to rebuild, though. Sure, it took some time. His first three teams didn't qualify for postseason play. But his fourth and fifth teams made the NCAA Tourmament. He won 22 and 21 games in those seasons, respectively. And, in the process, he assembled a few recruiting classes ranked in the top 15 in the country.

Those are all reasons why Heath's firing sparked some outrage nationally. His mentor, Michigan State's Tom Izzo, said he felt "almost vindictive." ESPN college basketball analyst Jay Bilas said the decision proved that "Frank Broyles doesn't have any idea what he is doing."

Then again, Izzo and Bilas aren't down here. They aren't in Fayetteville, where season-ticket sales and actual attendance had dropped steadily. So Broyles, who's announced he's stepping down in December, felt like he had to make the decision, keeping in mind, of course, the apathy shown by fans and the concern exhibited by boosters.

By doing so, Broyles proved the decreasing influence of Arkansas Chancellor John White, who helped bring Heath and former women's basketball coach Susie Gardner to Arkansas. White privately gave Heath a vote of confidence, a gesture he couldn't see through.

Also, by being appointed as the lone person in charge of finding Arkansas' next coach, Broyles was given full clearance to make the hire that could shape his legacy. Interestingly, White has had no role in the basketball coach search, even though he is leading the search for Broyles' replacement.

In fact, no one seems to be assisting Broyles as he scours the coaching ranks. Simply put, this has angered and mystified many fans and boosters.

They find themselves asking: Does an 82-year-old ex-football coach have what it takes to mold the future of the Arkansas basketball program?

Broyles hasn't spoken publicly about the process.

But a close confidant of Broyles can't believe he's not consulting others, people who know more about basketball than the Arkansas AD. If Broyles can't lock down a coach that would thrill the masses, that would sell the tickets that went unsold, he will catch immense heat.

And he should.

It's a tough sell to get rid of a coach who made two straight NCAA Tournament appearances. It's a tougher sell when the person leading the search appears to have gone through Plans A, B and C, leaving him to interview candidates in Atlanta.

The only deduction Broyles' friend can form from how the situation unfolded is that Broyles expected the search to be easy and swift.

Two words may have led Broyles to think that way.

Billy Gillispie.

Over the past month, secretive talks between representatives of Gillispie and the university took place, a source close to the program said. These chats likely molded Broyles' thinking. Gillispie showed immense interest. The representatives tossed around salary figures.

Simply put, Gillispie seemed highly intrigued by a possible Arkansas opening.

But, it's evident that not enough communication was delivered between these representatives and Broyles. After Broyles fired Heath, Gillispie refused to return phone calls from Broyles. So did Texas A&M Athletic Director Bill Byrne. In the meantime, the representatives had only limited discussions.

All of a sudden, Gillsipie to Arkansas wasn't even close to the "done deal" the representatives believed it would be. And Broyles seemed puzzled, frozen even. All he could do was wait by the phone.

Byrne finally called on Thursday morning, and Broyles was unable to reach Gillispie during a two-hour window. After the two-hour period, Byrne called back again to say that Gillispie was staying in College Station.

Panic mode surely ensued. No other similar contacts had been made with coaches who might be interested. As was said throughout, it was Gillispie or bust.

Well, Arkansas busted. Broyles took off for Atlanta a day later and interviewed candidates, refusing to take calls or discuss his search methods at all.

The entirety of the week has left fans on edge.

All they can think is, "Who now?"

Those close to the program said money wasn't an option, and it still isn't. Actually, it now looks like Arkansas won't have to shell out as much money as it once thought.

Initially, with names such as Gillispie, Kansas' Bill Self and Southern California's Tim Floyd out there, the conventional thought was that Arkansas would have to pony up. Nearly $2 million per year, probably.

But now, as the candidates list has swelled (and big names dropped), Broyles could land a bargain buy.

Which now brings us to the ultimate question. Who will coach Arkansas next season?

Realism must first dictate the list. It seems as if Gillispie, Self, Floyd and UNLV's Lon Kruger are out of the picture. Those four big names likely would've satisfied Arkansas' fan base, the main criteria that people must remember right now.

Broyles didn't get rid of Heath strictly because of on-court performance, though Arkansas' maddening inconsistency did impact the decision. He made a change because of the lagging interest in the program. With 20,000-seat Bud Walton Arena and top-notch facilities, Arkansas is the type of place where a big-time coach could thrive.

Fans know that, and Broyles realizes that. More than anything, he needs to fill seats. He needs to get donations to The Razorback Foundation back up.

He needs to land a big splash, someone who will immediately inject excitement into the now-lethargic fanbase.

Unfortunately, there are precious few coaches left like that who would be willing to come to Fayetteville. Five jump out, however.

The most intriguing is Memphis coach John Calipari, Arkansas' new No. 1 target, according to several sources close to both basketball programs. The sources said Calipari was offered the job on Friday in Atlanta by Broyles.

Calipari has a 181-63 record in seven seasons at Memphis, went to the Final Four with Massachusetts and coached the New Jersey Nets for two-plus seasons.

Rick Majerus has shown interest, and he took Utah to the Final Four before joining ESPN as an analyst. Mike Montgomery helped Stanford advance to the Final Four and coached the Golden State Warriors. He is now out of coaching. Jamie Dixon keeps arising among fans. Dixon is 105-30 in four years as Pittsburgh's coach. Bruce Weber got to the national championship game with Illinois and has indicated interest.

Beyond that, Broyles would be hiring a coach relatively unknown to Arkansans. That did work with the hiring of Eddie Sutton, then at Creighton, and Richardson, then at Tulsa. And it could work again if Broyles finds a coach whose style of play would appease fans who enjoy an up-tempo pace.

There are plenty of options out there. As far as experienced coaches, Creighton's Dana Altman, Wichita State's Mark Turgeon, Oral Roberts' Scott Sutton and Winthrop's Gregg Marshall would no doubt listen. Relatively inexperienced possibilities include Southern Illinois' Chris Lowery, Virginia Commonwealth's Anthony Grant and New Mexico State's Reggie Theus.

Even Oklahoma State's Sean Sutton has had his name tossed around by several college basketball commentators.

But this time around, fans are expecting more than a mid-major find. They expect more because of the way Heath was shown the door. They expect more because of their expectations.

They expect more because they felt confident Arkansas' name and stature could draw a big-time coach to return the Hogs to big-time success.

Unfortunately, Broyles' actions -- or inaction -- might have gotten in the way.




Reader Comments (31 comment(s))


The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsibility of their authors. The Morning News does not review comments before their publication, nor do we guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by our comment policy. If you see a comment that violates our policy, please notify the web editor.

dbird12 wrote on Mar 31, 2007 10:19 PM:

" Coach Broyles brought Nolan Richardson to Arkansas. I am outraged by the statement. Frank Broyles does have what it takes to find the right basketball coach. Take a look down Razorback road. Enough said. "

Mike wrote on Mar 31, 2007 10:37 PM:

" Broyles hired Nolan over 20 years ago. Since then, he hasn't done much right. He should've retired years ago.Unfortunately, no one at the university has had the heart to take the keys away from him. "

Smedlap wrote on Mar 31, 2007 11:27 PM:

" What a stupid article. The coach search doesn't go as quickly as hoped and now a silly local sportswriter suggests that maybe Heath shouldn't have been fired. Everybody get this straight: Heath should have been fired because he was a lousy bench coach. Period. So the search for a new coach is taking some time. So what. Doesn't negate the obvious point that Heath couldn't coach in a game. The Arkansas b-ball fans aren't stupid. They know when a coach is underperforming. That's why attendance and sales were down. Frank made the right decision to get rid of Heath, and whoever replaces him will have success with this talent. The Hogs will be back sooner than all the pessimists think. "

dbird12 wrote on Mar 31, 2007 11:58 PM:

" Coach Broyles is still capable. Mike you are hoping you can still get around when you are Coach Broyles age. Mike you are lacking the facts. Dave Van Horn was hired by Broyles. Bryne was the AD at Nebraska. Bryne is the AD at Texas A&M. He is still mad Broyles got Van Horn to come back to Arkansas. Ok, Mike shouldn't you get to bed early you have a paper route you need to finish early Sunday morning. Get the facts before you make stupid comments on the message board. We love you Coach. "

Norm wrote on Apr 1, 2007 12:26 AM:

" I never agree with anyone....but Smedlap, you are on point...Heath was fired because he can't coach. This team looked LOST too often. No matter who they hire, I promise you they look more like a well-coached team next year....because they will be. "

gahog wrote on Apr 1, 2007 2:26 AM:

" Whoever we get will be better than Heath. C'mon Calipari please be our guy. "

Pickles077 wrote on Apr 1, 2007 6:24 AM:

" The bungling being done is by the writer of this article. Why are there not requirements for being a sports writer? "

dirtysouth wrote on Apr 1, 2007 7:02 AM:

" this reads more like an editorial than an article - and poorly done either way. i bet this writer is glad he isn't judged daily by the masses. obviously he has never been to fayetteville...otherwise he'd know that Coach Broyles does indeed, have a clue. "

DallasRazorback wrote on Apr 1, 2007 7:53 AM:

" They say that good story tellers never let the facts get in the way of a good story. A few facts about U/A men's atheletic program since coach Broyles arrival in 1958. Fact 1: The football program is top 20 in wins and winning percentage. Fact 2: The basketball program is top 10 in winning percentage,top 10 NCAA tourneyment appearances,wins, and winning percentage. Fact 3: The baseball program is currently #7 and plays in the finest collegiate facility in the NATION and will lead the nation in attendace this year. Fact 4:Track & Field 43 National Championships in 24 years Fact 5: Only division 1 school top 25 in football & basketball, elt alone throw in the baseball. Coach Broyles is DIRECTLY responsible for these facts. Now as for your article.While you do make afew good points the theme of your article is completely off base. Granted Stan Heath is leaving the program in better shape than he found it.And while these things are always a matter of judgement, I would agree that what we were seeing was as good as it was going to get and that was not going to be good enough for we expect on the hill. Coach Broyles performance of his job over the last 50 years is nothing short of brilliant. With no state money or student fees we have TOP of line facilities in ALL sports. Without Coach Broyles what does Arkansas have to crow about? Poultry production? "

To D.R. wrote on Apr 1, 2007 8:15 AM:

" Expand on what you meant by in fact #5. What about Texas, Florida, USC, UCLA, Tenn., and I can name several others but maybe I didn't understand what you were saying. Are you saying Ar. is the only school with the FB and BB teams ranked in the Top 25? "

okiehawg wrote on Apr 1, 2007 8:41 AM:

" This will define Frank's legacy? Give me a break. The man has been there 50 years and this one hire will define his legacy? What are these reporters smoking? Just read the facts from DallasRazorback. Just drive though the campus. Just think he just completed raising $1 BILLION for non- athletic needs at the UA! And one coach hire at the end of his career will define his legacy. These writers need to look past their live spans which seem to be no more than 12 years. I just do not understand the continuous vinum this newspaper spews at Frank Broyles. "

Jersey Rick wrote on Apr 1, 2007 8:48 AM:

" I think taking 1 week to hire a multi-million dollar employee is very reasonable. This person will be in charge of a lot of things and will command a huge salary. In the real world, such an employee could take weeks or months to find and hire. Premier basketball coaches don't grow on trees - sportswriters do - and guys like Malashock are a dime a dozen. With all the various forms of sports media out there, ANYBODY can be a "sportswriter" and guys like this prove it. "

isu861 wrote on Apr 1, 2007 8:51 AM:

" Do you seriously want your readers to believe that Bill Self would leave Kansas, Tim Floyd (with Mayo coming in) would leave USC, and Bruce Weber leave Illinois for Arkansas? Please share with us the logic for these coaches to even consider Arkansas based on their current jobs? "

IDIOTIC ARTICLE wrote on Apr 1, 2007 9:21 AM:

" This paper has become a JOKE! It's become an outlet for couch potato's to pompously blow about their alledged sports knowledge - even tho few likely were able to play at the High School level. And this supposed writer ... WITH Coach Broyles at the helm the Univ. of Arkansas has been able to build the most prestigous on-campus facilities for Men's and Women's sports - I dare you to find ONE other NCAA Div. I school with as fine a set of facilities!!!! And at NO COST to the taxpayers of Arkansas! And it WAS THIS PAPER and it's "bloggers" who just two-weeks ago were screaming for Heath's head, in spite of the student/atheletes winning their way into the NCAA tournament. What a crock! Wish Tyson or the Walton family would buy out this proverbial joke, fire the whole lot of "reporters" [sic] and hire a new crew from the New York Times. It may be a basition of liberalism, but at least the New Yorkers admit their bias. "

R_U_Nutts wrote on Apr 1, 2007 9:57 AM:

" All the coaches I have heard mentioned by broyles and his mouthpieces, fit one profile. They are .......WHITE! "

Fred wrote on Apr 1, 2007 10:26 AM:

" Get your facts straight, Mr. so-called "sports writer." Jimmy Dykes knows a little about BB. Coach Broyles is consulting with Jimmy in this coaching search. Makes me wonder what else you got 180 degrees dead wrong. "

Doggtown31LCC wrote on Apr 1, 2007 11:50 AM:

" I believe Broyles did the right thing, Heath is good guy and a good coach, but not an excellent coach. He's a decent recruiter and can get good talent, but in my opinion he can't get a team to mesh well, look what Richardson did, I'm not saying I like what he did at the end of his tenure, you can't win at any level starting 5 guards even if one of them is Joe Johnson, back to my point Nolan never had one NBA All-Star on any of his teams throughout the 90's and look what he accomplished. He could find guys like Cory Beck, Scotty Thurman and many others that weren't high school all-stars and make great teams. They beat some teams that were loaded with NBA talent. I Believe thats what Arkansas needs, someone who can do these things. I believe thats what brought so much intensity to Razorback Basketball games that and "40 Minutes of Hell". Arkansas had something that not many teams had, I mean coaches had to changeup there whole routine just to play the hogs, adding 2 or 3 more players to their scrimmage just to simulate their press. I believe thats what filled the seats having something nobody else had. It was just so thrilling watching them play, if their is coach like this and i knew about him, he would be somewhere already making millions. So goodluck Broyles with your search, bring us back to GLORY. "

Doggtown31LCC wrote on Apr 1, 2007 11:56 AM:

" TDArk, I agree Anderson would be my pick too, when i saw ark play missouri this year, they were identicle to what a Richardson team looked like. "

Pig Slop wrote on Apr 1, 2007 1:12 PM:

" Without Frank Broyles......Arkansas.......would be............an Arkansas State........... in athletics. I don't give a flip how old JFB is, he is still sharp and doing the best for the University of Arkansas. Thanks Coach Broyles for what you've done!! They know not what they say for their ignorance is bliss. "

MC wrote on Apr 1, 2007 1:20 PM:

" It was a good move to get rid of Heath. Sure we have good players coming back what beyong that ? Face it folks, the man was a very weak coach. He already had an established team to start out with at Kent State. Big Deal if it takes a little longer to find a coach - I'll bet we find one before Kentucky does. It will work out for this Razorback nation and we will be fine. If Heath would have been told he only had one more year to prove himself - NO descent recruits would have come around he we did not go far into the tournament next season. Broyles will find a good one - not a decision we need to rush into just because the fans want one found !! "

MC wrote on Apr 1, 2007 1:31 PM:

" You ask "How could Gillispie get away" ? Are you kidding me ! He is getting a huge raise, has an established team, getting a 22 million dollar practice facility - Don't kid yourselves, you wouldn't leave either ! I could see some of these coaches leaving their programs if they weren't paid well, but Oh they are paid very well. "

Ronnie Stonestreet wrote on Apr 1, 2007 2:34 PM:

" When I watched Arkansas beat West Virginia in the Old Spice Classic, I could see they had great players, but not great bench coaching, thought they would go a long way this year. End of season was very good, Heath was a good recruiter and the next coach will be in good shape. "

Depressed Hog wrote on Apr 1, 2007 4:37 PM:

" Frank Broyles = CLUSTERFRANK... "

hoggy wrote on Apr 1, 2007 4:44 PM:

" Heath should have been fired the second Mike Conley Jr. signed with OSU, he didn't even call one of the best players in the country! "

Nadir wrote on Apr 1, 2007 5:50 PM:

" the athletic department is a catastrophe; broyles is an old man: grasping, hanging on, holding on, humiliating himself and the university in the process. NUTT, well NUTT is an embarassment to himself, his community, the university and razorback football fans. "

KS hogfan wrote on Apr 1, 2007 7:39 PM:

" As the dust settles, we see that Heath, the mentor, class-act coach, who took the team to the tourney for the second year in a row was fired, and a week later the Razorbacks have asked permission to talk to a coach whose googled name brings up descriptions such as "snake-oil salesman." The Patrick Beverly's of the world will by-pass UA. A coach's personal qualities matter to the families of these young recruits,and should matter to fans. Has Arkansas decided it needs to win at any cost? "

Kelly Girl wrote on Apr 1, 2007 7:43 PM:

" Some of the comments on this site are just vile about Frank Broyles. He's done more for the University of Arkansas than anyone, and he does know how to pick a winning coach. Stan Heath couldn't coach, was boring and didn't have any fire when it came to the Razorbacks. It was just a job. FB loves the Hogs, and he wants what is best for the fans and the University. Little Rock loves and trusts him and more power to him. When I was a student at the UofA, I worked for the student newspaper and as a freshman, the editor sent me out to do a story on the Razorbacks and told me to interview FB. The editor thought it was funny, but the joke was on him. FB agreed to meet with me, and couldn't have been nicer. He spent an hour with a "green" little freshman girl. That's the kind of person FB is ... always time for students, fans and the Hogs. "

Franks problem wrote on Apr 1, 2007 10:31 PM:

" Frank should have retired at the end of 2006 if he really cared about our Athletic program. His bad decisions will put us back 10 years or longer. "

tnew wrote on Apr 2, 2007 12:36 AM:

" Well written and composed article. Fans, it is hard to say it and admit it. From someone that had a pretty close relationship to Coach Broyles during my time on campus. He needed to put all of his energy into appointing a successor for his job. That should be his primary focus. The Heath and Nutt sagas that have occured in the past couple of months would never have happened with a younger Coach Broyles, not to mention the Richardson drama 5 years ago. That should have been a wake up. The Heath firing/new basketball coach hiring, especially going after the big names, looks like a last stab toward greatness. The biggest void in the program is the AD. Heath should have been retained so that Coach could have spent this time going headlong into finding his replacement, training that replacement and transitioning smoothly. I have been critical of Coach for a while but make no mistake about it. He was great for the program. He was. "

BluffHawg wrote on Apr 2, 2007 8:00 AM:

" I'm starting to feel like Arkansas is the ugly guy that can't find a date to the prom. However, I can't say that I blame the top coaches when you look at the way our fan base treats head coaches. "

Illini1 wrote on Apr 6, 2007 11:48 AM:

" Why would Lon Kruger or for God's sake, Bill Self, leave Kansas to go to Arkansas?? That's like quiting your executive high profile job to work at McDonalds drive thru. "


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Not already registered?
Register Now