Gravette Mayor Predicts 10 Percent Cut In 2009
Last updated Friday, September 19, 2008 9:05 PM CDT in News
By Caleb Fort
THE MORNING NEWS
GRAVETTE -- Mayor Bill Howard said he will ask city departments to cut back their 2009 budgets by 10 percent.
For Gravette, which has struggled with low sales tax revenue this year, that probably means a reduction in services, Howard said.
The library has cut back its new book purchases -- the small 2008 shelf is mostly empty -- and all city departments are operating on reduced budgets.
But that won't be enough if next year's revenue is the same as this year's, Howard said.
Howard estimated the city will end 2008 having spent $1.3 million to $1.4 million. He wants that cut to $1.2 million in 2009.
The city's biggest problem is in sales taxes, which fell short of estimates by about $133,000 as of August. Howard blames that on new tax laws and a slow economy.
Howard said he will ask his department heads to make those cuts in their budget proposals, he said.
"Some of them ain't going to like it, I'm sure," he said. "But if the money's not there, there's not much choice."
Department heads said they don't know how they can make more cuts.
Kimberley Gibson, the library manager, said more cuts will mean fewer books, fewer programs and a possible reduction in hours.
The library already has cut back on purchases, and relies on donations to pay for speakers and story times, Gibson said.
One example of the library's already strained situation is in its reference room, where the encyclopedia is 13 years old.
"When you've got people coming in to study for school or for college, you just need something more recent," said library specialist Debra Meek.
Melissa Williams, a single mother of two, was using the Internet at the library on Friday. She said she would hate to see the library's budget shrink, because she uses the books and Internet connection "to stay in touch with the real world."
"I really think the library should be a No. 1 priority," she said. "It's really important for people who can't afford computers or books."
Junior Hartley, the director of public works, said he does not know where he will make cuts. His department has stopped new projects this year.
"We've really cut to the bare bones," he said. "We're just down to maintenance," such as patching streets.
Police Chief Trent Morrison also said he does not know where more cuts can come from. His department has put a mileage cap on police cruisers and held back on training and vehicle maintenance.
Planning Director Darren Warren said he has stopped using city vehicles, and buys his own fuel for business trips.
"I guess I'd rather just pay for my own gas than have them see me spending $30 of city money on it and getting rid of my job," he said. "I guess I don't really mind."
Warren also makes changes to planning maps by coloring in areas with a marker instead of printing out a new map.
Terry Gosnell, the city's building inspector and code enforcement officer, got rid of his office phone and uses his personal cell phone for work.
"I'm just trying to help out," he said.
At A Glance
Gravette Budget
• Gravette Mayor Bill Howard said the city will have to cut its 2009 budget by about 10 percent, or $130,000 to $140,000.
• The cut is to make up for a sales tax shortfall of more than $130,000.
• City department heads, who have already made reductions this year, said they might have to reduce services to meet the mayor's goal.
Source: Staff Report
Reader Comments (45 comment(s))
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsibility of their authors. The Morning News does not review comments before their publication, nor do we guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by our comment policy. If you see a comment that violates our policy, please notify the web editor.
ozarks wrote on Sep 20, 2008 8:04 AM:
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 12:19 PM:
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 12:30 PM:
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 12:44 PM:
Gravette has long been known for having quite a July 4th celebration. Every July 4th for years literally thousands of Gravette citizens and those from surrounding areas gather around sunset to watch what has been quite a good show. The show put on by Gravette was comparable to that of even some of the larger communities in NWA such as Siloam Springs, Bentonville or others. This was a source of pride and enjoyment in the Gravette community. Now, Ozarks might say that getting rid of the July 4th show was a good thing and as a single mother she would advise us all to buy our own sparklers and wave them around and congratulate ourselves on our cleverness. But, my perspective is that nearly every single person attending those celebrations went to the numerous retail establishments IN GRAVETTE to obtain chips, candy, drinks, ice, hotdogs, hamburgers, buns and while in Gravette walked the downtown district and got their hair cut or done and went to eat at Sonic or the other restaurants, got gas and heaven forbid even bought fireworks. Now, I don't remember if any of the fireworks stands were in city limits but every other item I mentioned would have been purchased in Gravette city limits and so would have generated revenue. But since Gravette didn't have one, all that money went to Siloam or other cities for their show. "
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 12:54 PM:
I want to preface my comments by saying that I do not blame the previous librarians nor would I say I am entirely sure "everthing" the current librarian does is perfect. But, I will say that anyone who has been around since before the current libray manager will certainly recognize that it isn't even the same place anymore. The curent library manager has turned a musty old building whos collection of books and tapes might not even compare favorably to my own to what we could describe as a REAL library. While GRavette's library does not have the facilities or the resources of others like those in Fort Smith, Fayetteville or Bentonville it is a RICH resource for improving the Gravette Community at its core, that or its literacy, its social fabric and its connection to world. One might be suprised, obviously Ozarks will be, to hear that there a a large number of students from the local schools who leave school to study at the library. They can either go home, wander the streets or go to the library. Ozarks might prefer the to wander the streets in an instructure environment so that "the village" can deal with them, but I'm betting that parents, teachers, and the GRavette PD would prefer them in the Library. "
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 1:03 PM:
How about the adults?
There are people who are file their taxes, research novels they are writing, take college courses online, manage stock portfolios, and run online businesses from the computers provided at the library. Many, if not most of these are disabled or retire persons and very restricted incomes. If they didn't have this their quality of life would be much reduced. Imagine if the potentially hundreds of people that derive portions of their incomes or educations from this resource were to move away because the library could no longer provide the services. Hmmm. might be even less tax revenue. "
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 1:14 PM:
Some of the most pleasant and helpful people you could hope to know. They do their best on already thin budgets to provide a much more couteous service than what you get in the larger libraries. These people know your name, they remember you you and genuinely want to know how you are doing when they ask you how you are doing. They bend over backwards to help you. And the library manager herself is quite passionate about providing whatever she can to help area residents have the services they need.
It's not just the library either. Why, I even remember a story about the city planner that Ozarks would like to get rid of (Let's not even comment on the stupidity of the idea of trying to grow a city without planning it). A gravette citizen and his son were on their way back from Bentonville and ran out of gas just a mile or two from teh Hiwasse gas station. They set out walking and it was very cold out. Darren Warren happened to be on his way back into town, maybe from lunch, with out hesitation it seems he stopped and asked if he could help and spent the next few minutes helping the stranded father and son get out of the cold, get gas and get to the station. "
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 1:22 PM:
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 1:34 PM:
I don't really thing NWAOnline has the storage space to hold all my comments so I'll comment only a little bit further.
Ozarks, I think that you probably would have a different attitude if your employer requested that you drive to Little Rock or fly some where or make hundreds of dollars of phone calls and then refused to reimburse you.
What you also fail to mention, Ozarks, is that some of the city departments have some large ONE-TIME expenses related to their budgets that have little to do with operating budgets. When calculating actual operation expenses for next year the city should not be counting these. Oh yeah, they have to be paid for, and maybe they shouldn't have been purchased in the first place. But remember it was the Mayor who was defending them just a few months ago acting like he was defending several of the departments from undue cuts by a city council panicking for no other reason than because some other citizen with a number of financial and physical interests in the city, particularly, downtown was leading the council around by the nose with misleading budget analyses. Trust me, I say some of his letters accusing the Mayor. And though I think the Mayor has not been doing his job, I also know enough accounting to know that this citizen was misrepesenting numbers to scare cooperation. "
Empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 1:38 PM:
This certainly is NOT a case of a Mayor just trying to keep "on the pulse" of the city budget. Maybe a Mayor trying to figure out what went wrong while he was napping or paying attention to other things. OK, I am being urged by my spouse to stop writing, so I will. "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 2:48 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 4:25 PM:
Maybe I wasn't clear. I'm sure I was but maybe not.
I have a problem with the person I mentioned making accusations against the Mayor and using as evidence of such, highly questionable numbers he claims to get directly from the city budgets. Having seen his numbers and the way he presented them in the city council meetings they were unfair attacks on the Mayor. This individual specifically used detailed budget items for YTD expenses and extrapolated the end of year expenses based on such with little regard to the one-time-expenses I mentioned previous. He then used YTD revenues, typically lower during the first quarters for most communities I believe, to extrapolate an extreme picture of budget shortfalls. He then quoted the Mayor saying everything is OK and questioned his honesty and/or his abilty to mange the budget or even his knowledge of the budget. The person mentioned only backed off when the Mayor invited the city attorney to the council meetings to hear the accusations and petitions to remove or somehow censure the Mayor. So here I am not atacking the Mayor but I am in defense of him based on the unscrupulous methods used by this opponent of his. "
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 4:35 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 4:48 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:04 PM:
Some people only shop in Gravette because they can stop by the library too. Twenty more minutes and they can be at WalMart and a bigger library but they stay here and spend here. Parents hoping to augment their own or their children's education deserve a good functioning Library with useful full time hours and trained personnel. Not everyone can afford a PC and Internet.
For a while Gravette seemed to be replacing some bad old sidewalk and those without vehicles were able to get around easier. But that improvement has slowed or stopped and there are still important areas on the side of a busy highway that are dangerous to walk on. We have a lot of people in town who walk to work and to shop in town. Some roads are is need of patching and another winter will make them need to be replaced rather than repaired.
Capping police mileage threatens our puiblic safety.
Parks in disrepair and rickety, failing, broken and dangerous parkbenches are a danger too. Kids can, have and will get hurt.
When these things as well as others a termed "luxuries" it make one wonder what the necessities are. "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:15 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:23 PM:
The Mayor was telling city managers eveything is OK.
Someone accused the Mayor of being ignorant of the situation or complicit in mismanagement.
Now the Mayor is trying to cut 10% ON TOP of previous requested cuts.
This article only reported the latest 10% cuts; it did not report the accusations, the Mayor's denial there was to be budget shortfalls, the Mayor's changing stance, or a lot of things so all we got was a puff piece making the Mayor look like a beleaguered hero with greedy city managers angry they have to cut bloated budgets. This article looks like someone's attempt to get ahead of the bad press that is sure to come once details start getting aired.
Then we have people online saying libraries are dead and not needed, streets don't need to be kept up, police to patrol, parks mowed, park benches repaired and that revenue generating community events are about as useful as a moist gross of Black Cats in the hands of a pyromaniacal 8 year old.
I admit the hyperbole is mine but something needs to be done because neither the Mayor nor his detractors or the council are giving it to us straight and I rail at them all until they come clean.
Gravette has come a long way the past few years. It shouldn't go backward! "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:25 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:35 PM:
Do you not read?
All I want are answers.
The Mayors changes his stance. Why?
Someone was trying to get the Mayor removed. Why?
That someone attempted to do so with questionable means. Why? What was in it for the Mayor's accuser?
I'm not a manger, I'm not the Mayor, I'm not on the council now am I personally or professionally involved in the politics any more than any local resident would wish to be. I have no position in the city either volunteer or paid have never nor likely willever atempt to hold elects or represented office.
I ahve no axe to grind and bear no grudges against any one in the area.
But there are irregularities here. Answers are not forthcoming. Most Gravette citizens will only notice that one day the Library closes and it won't open again. They'll be a party to a law suit against the city for broken playground equipment or benches. Businesses will lose patrons and/or refuse to move in because city services and roads are not kept up. We'll notice that police cars will be randomly parked on corners and driveways, rarely moved and having no police in them. And suprisingly tax revenue will sink even lower. School millages will suffer, that giant new shiny school will begin to fall apart and those who can will move away.
I don't want that to happen to Gravette. "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:37 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:37 PM:
"I'm not a manger, I'm not the Mayor, I'm not on the council NOR am I personally or professionally involved in the politics any more than any local resident would wish to be. I have no position in the city either volunteer or paid have never nor likely willever atempt to hold elects or represented office. " "
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:41 PM:
I used an "unnamed citizen" not as prrof but as an example of how muddled this situation is.
This person attacked the Mayor, and did so in a way I find reprehensible. "
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 5:57 PM:
I myself on a very few occasions have been there either in the mornings or in the evenings, and have witnessed the Library usage. It is very much a different place than it was a few years ago when you could go a whole day sometimes and have only a handfull of people show up.
You don't even want to get me started about my "silver" spoon!
My childhood was spent in a home with no AC. I didn't live in a place with AC until I left home and joined the military. I can remember using an outhouse because dad hadn't finished installing the indoor toilet. I remember my mother crying in the night saying something like "What are we going to feed the boys tomorrow." In college (paid for by me and not by any family member)I got kicked out of class because I was a veteran (in the professor's vernacular an "imperalist baby killer") and felt the government (at any level) should be fiscally conservative rather than a nanny state, and this although my academic performance was, in a word, stellar! I have been harrassed for being "too honest" by employers. And I provide for a family with hard work, honesty and integrity. "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 6:03 PM:
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 6:20 PM:
Nothing better than a book you can turn the pages of.
The Internet can be so biased as to be useless unless you have substantial abilities to be properly critical about its content and sources. It's useful but is truly not a mature information source, but is getting there.
RE bad attitude:
Shoot yeah I have a bad attitude about what is going on. I see people not being completely forthcoming on issues so the people of Gravette can make informed decisions.
RE Got it out for the Mayor:
I do not know the man. Might have caught a glimps of him outside the City Hall one day, but not for sure. I do have numerous trusted sources saying both mean and nasty as well as very positive things about him. I have heard/read the comments of city council members, heard friends and family members of city managers and saw an email and the "call to action" petition of one of his detractors concerning budget anomalies. I also understand that some people in those city meetings may have made recordings or taken notes which demostrate the contradictory positiions the Mayor seems to have taken as well as the attacks by his detractors.
RE Libel:
The Mayor is a public figure. Libel is a very narrow legal topic not applicable here. I have not accused him of anything other than apparently changing positions and hoping he'll explain why "all is well" then "the sky is falling." "
empiricus wrote on Sep 23, 2008 6:32 PM:
Your loss if you don't want to come and see our town while it still has something to offer.
Maybe if you came to the well run library, watched happy children in the park, heard and felt the oohs and ahhhs at the fireworks display, witnessed the dedication of our police and fire crews as they protect us, saw the results of a job well done by our road crews you would see that they already do so much to make this town worth living in. But they do so with resource already shortened. They all go the extra mile. Now, after being told it's all OK, then getting cut they are getting cut again.
Whether it's the Mayor, the council or other interlopers, Gravette citizens have right to know what is going on, but they are only being told part of the story, and that story keeps changing. "
ozarks wrote on Sep 23, 2008 9:08 PM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 9:16 AM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 9:16 AM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 9:17 AM:
As shown in this report, its hard to argue that there is a trend for this communitys government to be too lax when it comes to our finances and the accounting of them. Mr. Howards figures for 2007 and what I think could easily be anticipated for 2008 only go to serve that trend. As for me, I dont think its an easy sell to call my efforts reprehensible or even attribute them solely to an interest inpersonal enrichment. Im simply trying to call a spade a spade. Again, I think democracy gives each of us that right and responsibility.
It may come as no surprise to either of the others who have commented here, but I have filed to run as an alderman here in Gravette. I hope to be a small part of an effort to bring a renewed sense of fiscal responsibility to our fine city as well as a renewed confidence in the direction of our local government and our community as a whole. "
justinnkim99 wrote on Sep 25, 2008 9:29 AM:
second..I've lived in Gravette for almost 19 year's...and I've NEVER even set foot in the library...when we wanted to study in school...we generally did that with friends..or at home...
If something needs to get cut...the library would be the first thing I"d cut...NOT the parks and recreation department..or PD.
This past summer our parks/recreation department got cut back and we had the WORST looking baseball field in NWA - it was an embarrasment to say the least...let's keep up and spend our money on something that brings in hundreds of people nightly - at least Monday/Tuesday/Thursday and Friday - and an occasional Saturday for 3 months -and then soccer start's..it's a park that is ALWAYS busy and needs to be a priority in the town..I totally agree that we should have kept the July 4th festivities...the money spent on the firecrackers was money donated by various businesses..Volunteer FF were the ones that volunteered their time to over see the handling of the works...
it's just a sad situation...
FIX THE INTERSECTION DOWN TOWN ALREADY!!! IT'S AWFUL!!! "
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:34 AM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 10:52 AM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:09 AM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:17 AM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:23 AM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:38 AM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 11:48 AM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:15 PM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:16 PM:
phall wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:19 PM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:32 PM:
ozarks wrote on Sep 25, 2008 12:43 PM:
How many vehicles id owned by the city? How many are taken home by empoyees? How many work in your water and sewer department? How many cops do you have? How many visitors went and checked out a book at your libaray last month (August). What projects is your city planner woking? How many building inspections were completed last month? How many tickets did you cops write last month and how many crimes were investigated and I don mean grandma locked herself out of her car or there is a dog running around town. I mean crime if any at all? How many times was the fire department was called out and actually had to do something? (I have a lot of respect for firemen/women I will add). What kind of data or information do you have to fix your budget problems. Just wondering how much you really have done. I could go on but do you know the answers to these simple questions? I would if I were an alderman or trying to tell all I have the fix? Good luck to your little town and Hope you don't take the direction of Suplhur Springs, Centerton, Decatur, Centerton, Greenville. We have pleanty of things to read in the funny papers. You can join them if you like or you fix things that need it without pointing fingers or looking for a pat on the back. "


ozarks wrote on Sep 20, 2008 7:57 AM: