Elm Springs Forced To Make Decision On Fire Protection

Tontitown Price Tag Will Almost Double After Jan. 1

Last updated Friday, November 28, 2008 7:50 PM CST in News

By Bob Caudle
THE MORNING NEWS

    "Star Wars" may be passe, but a spin-off, Fire Wars, is heating up in northwest Washington County.

    The Tontitown Area Volunteer Fire Department is seeking more money from Elm Springs for fire coverage this year -- a lot more money.

    The Tontitown group wants $49,000 next year, up from the $28,000 per year that Elm Springs pays, according to Mick Wagner.

    Wagner was recently replaced by Becky Alston on the Tontitown Fire Department's Commission. Wagner now serves as an unpaid consultant to the group.

    Elm Springs has been paying the tab to Tontitown for fire protection for its residents for years, Elm Springs officials said.

    Elm Springs spends $178,000 per year for police protection and is spending $28,000 per year for fire protection, according to Wagner. The majority of Tontitown's calls to Elm Springs during the past year, Wagner added, were for medical emergencies.

    "While we were at the council meeting talking about fire rates, they introduced two new police officers," Wagner said. "I honestly don't know what's more important to Elm Springs officials -- a heart attack or a speeding ticket."

    Wagner said Tontitown officials based Elm Springs costs on the assessed dollar per building and went to the county clerk for evaluations.

    "It's a simple formula to support charging Elm Springs residents a proportionate amount as the residents of Tontitown," Wagner said. "There's an Attorney General opinion that says that a fire department can't give away services. It also can't charge one guy $25 per house and another guy $75 per house.

    Tom Kieklak, the city attorney for Elm Springs, said the city is going to have to go elsewhere for fire coverage.

    "Right now, we're talking to Cave Springs," Kieklak said. "I think we're going to be able to work something out with the Cave Springs Fire Department."

    If there's not a contract with Tontitown signed by Jan. 1, Elm Springs residents will have to pay $75 per year per residence or $200 per year for each business to join the Tontitown Area Fire Department, Wagner said.

    Otherwise, if Tontitown firefighters respond to a fire at a residence or business that hasn't paid dues, the cost will be $1,000 for the first hour and $400 for each additional hour.

    "In the end, it's purely a financially decision," Kieklak said. "Since 2003, Elm Springs residents have not had to pay dues. City officials are trying very had to maintain that and still have the same, or better, fire protection."

    At A Glance



    Tontitown Fire Department

    The Tontitown Fire Department has 24 firefighters -- nine are certified EMTs, one is a certified paramedic, and 11 are designated first responders. The primary source of funding for the fire department comes from annual membership dues paid by residents in the coverage area. Membership dues are supplemented with fundraisers by firefighters.

    Source: Staff Report

    Reader Comments (7 comment(s))


    The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsibility of their authors. The Morning News does not review comments before their publication, nor do we guarantee their accuracy. By publishing a comment here you agree to abide by our comment policy. If you see a comment that violates our policy, please notify the web editor.

    outspokn wrote on Nov 28, 2008 10:00 PM:

    " a lot of things must be considered before switching to a different fire department. Does cave springs have the extra manpower and equipment to cover elm springs? the citizens of elm springs are sure to experience a longer response time from cave springs. Tontitown FD seems much more capable to provide the level of service required. Cave Springs FD doesnt have the best track record of saving property. "

    moneyfornothin wrote on Nov 28, 2008 10:24 PM:

    " I would pay 75.00 a year in a heartbeat, if I had the chance...and 200.00 for a business?? A cheap price to pay.
    If one place should catch on fire and burn and it will take on a whole new perspective...
    Tontitown has a first class fire department and always has...
    They are very dedicated. Those with first hand experience would know that.
    Those few would pay the 75.00 without blinking... "

    b4uwrite wrote on Nov 29, 2008 8:46 AM:

    " You can pay the $75 if you want, but do you want your city government handing that amount of money over to a private, not for profit corporation without any oversight? Elm Springs ask for a seat on the board in return and was told no. At lease the city controls its police. Tontitown residents should be outraged that their city hands over $120,000 and has absolutly no say in how it is spent or no proof of what it is spent on. Cave Springs is an excellent fire department and response times wont be any different. Kudos to Elm Springs for standing up for themselves and being responsible for their spending. "

    b4uwrite wrote on Nov 29, 2008 9:05 AM:

    " You can give them $1000 if you want. Bottom line, this fire department is a private not for profit corporation that until just months ago had no proper accounting. They are not audited by the state and have no oversight in how they spend their money. Shame on Tontitown for giving away $120,000 of tax payer money and not having any oversight in how it is spent. Cave Springs is a municiple fire department and does have oversight. Elm Springs ask for a seat on the tontitown fire department board of directors in return for the increased rate and was told no. When the city of tontitown needs a full time fire department all the rural victims can foot the bill. Elm Springs wont. And not just when the city of tontitown needs it, when the fire department decides they want it. They will do it, hand the city a bill and they WILL pay it or else. They have no say at all. And to compare the need to have police vs. fire....Apples and oranges. As a society we need both. "

    foxybunnie wrote on Dec 1, 2008 2:02 PM:

    " This is so stupid Elm Springs is seriously in need of an attitude adjustment, as well as Tontitowns Mick Wagner! Elm Springs did not need two new police officers especially one of whom that has such a long record of problems! Tontitown needs to be more reasonable an increase that much is too much! Maybe if Elm Springs would get new city officals it could make a change for the better because there are lots of unjust acts playing out that are going to catch up with them sooner than later! "

    clybar wrote on Dec 2, 2008 3:09 PM:

    " Elm Springs didn't get two "new" officers. They filled one vacant position in September and another in November. They have had 4 officers for some time. I haven't heard of any unjust acts. Was it unjust when Elm Springs decided to pay fire dues for its citizens years before Tontitown did? Is is unjust that Elm Springs doesn't think its citizens should pay for a fire department that is only growing because of the need of one city? What Elm Springs needs is some citizens that care about their community running for office or at least attending the meetings. "

    littleredrabbit@sbcglobal.net wrote on Dec 4, 2008 12:48 PM:

    " Okay think about it, and take the emotion out of the mix!
    Fact 1 – anything regarding Mick Wagner’s name attached is a negative, he’s a brute, and enjoys taking swipes at who and where ever he can, but he has the facts of the matter, sadly this is not an excuse for his behavior. As a citizen of Tontitown, I apologize for the reported comments by Mr. Wagner, regarding the Police Officers of Elm Springs. Fact 2 – in order to maintain the highly efficient TFD and the excellent service it provides you must be willing to provide financial support for equipment, personnel, and educational training for volunteers, and the future growth of the area, including Elm Springs. Unfortunately, it comes with a hefty increase to the town of Elm Springs and their budget. Perhaps some pre-warning should have been given. Count the population, divided by each household and/or business; do the math, a small price tag for the coverage provided. Ask your self, who do you want responding to a fire, accident, or a life-threatening situation? Been there done that, and the response time was phenomenal. First responder at the scene, Tontitown Volunteer Fire Department personnel, time of response, 5-7 min of the 911 call. Fire truck and transport, under 10 minutes with a capable, qualified volunteers. Care provided by team of trained individuals on the scene, EXCEPTIONAL! Orchestrated by, Mike Zulpo Fire Chief of Tontitown, and his department. Any more questions? Didn’t think so! "


    *Member ID:
    *Password:
      Forgot Your Password?
     

    Not already registered?
    Register Now

    Sponsors